Skip to main content

Hi, My ebay account has been suspended with the following message -

"You have been suspended from eBay because our records indicate your account was involved in activities that violate our policies."

On further questioning, they have stated that it was due to bids being placed by suspected automated bidding software of a country of origin inconsistant with my IP address.

What do you make of that?.
I can't really appeal it because it's true!!.

I must just take this opportunity to thank Auction Sniper - your service really has has improved 10 fold in the last few months!.

Farewell I guess, from senator30e.
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

quote:
posted Sep 22, 12:26 PM
Hi, My ebay account has been suspended with the following message -

"You have been suspended from eBay because our records indicate your account was involved in activities that violate our policies."

On further questioning, they have stated that it was due to bids being placed by suspected automated bidding software of a country of origin inconsistant with my IP address.


Are you US based or where? I find nothing in the policies US or Germany that say you cannot snipe.Perhaps I have missed something. I believe I emailed Ebay some time ago and was told sniping was acceptable. This was posted here. Are you sure you are suspended and it was not spoof mail?
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
I find nothing in the policies US or Germany that say you cannot snipe.Perhaps I have missed something.
Here’s something quick off Internet:
http://www.auctionbytes.com/cab/abn/y02/m12/i02/s01
There are other articles that come up in searching Internet.

There are 5 Click Here on the following click here:
>>> Click here <<<

I'm not sure this has actually been answered, or that we've just debated the heck out of it.
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
quote:
posted Sep 22, 12:26 PM
Hi, My ebay account has been suspended with the following message -

"You have been suspended from eBay because our records indicate your account was involved in activities that violate our policies."

On further questioning, they have stated that it was due to bids being placed by suspected automated bidding software of a country of origin inconsistant with my IP address.


Are you US based or where? I find nothing in the policies US or Germany that say you cannot snipe.Perhaps I have missed something. I believe I emailed Ebay some time ago and was told sniping was acceptable. This was posted here. Are you sure you are suspended and it was not spoof mail?


I am UK based and yes, I am sure. The initial message came up when I tried to log in to the 'My eBay' page. If you try to view my feedback it now says 'Not a registered user'
Wow, I haven't heard of this happening before.

They just lost themselves out of a great bidder.

I don't understand this. Their security bots are supposed to be built to detect fraudulent activity and eliminate it, correct? Yet they found a great eBay buyer from what I can tell and boot you instead? Then when you inform them of their mistake they won't resind your banning.

That's harsh.

Of course with a free Hotmail account you can just register and start bidding again, so I don't really understand what keeps bidders off that they kick off anyways, aren't they only training the bad guys how to get better at beating the system each time they kick them off, and nailing some of the good guys along the way too like our friend here?
quote:
Originally posted by senator30e:
quote:
Originally posted by Rick:
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
As far as a link from your auction to AS, it has been forbidden for a long time, of course.
Does that mean as the seller including a link on the auction for AS?


I am not a seller - never have been.
I have never put an Auction Sniper link anywhere.
Didn't think that was the case (due to your feedback). Wanted to try clear up M's question.
quote:
Originally posted by Puppy Raiser:
Maybe a German seller or another bidder reported their suspicions?
My understanding is that they have to prove it was from a sniping service, and not a manual snipe. Don't know how they could, but InstaMail would definitely be a clue. And, I thought it was up to the seller. Hard to think ebay wouldn't give someone a warning first, especially considering what they do with bid retractors.
quote:
Originally posted by Rick:
quote:
Originally posted by Puppy Raiser:
Now I'm confused... Has the senator been reinstated?

Maybe it was only a temporary suspension.
Good catch.

He was definitely NARU'd yesterday.


Yes - my account has been re-instated after a lot of pleading with eBay. I took the chance to put the snipers point accross - it is not the last bidder that wins an auction, it's the highest!. This they seemed to take on board and have let me use the account again with a warning. What can I say - I am now a commited Auction Sniper user and will continue to do so!!. Thanks for everyones help and comments - senator30e.
quote:
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
As far as a link from your auction to AS, it has been forbidden for a long time, of course.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Does that mean as the seller including a link on the auction for AS?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



I am not a seller - never have been.
I have never put an Auction Sniper link anywhere.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Didn't think that was the case (due to your feedback). Wanted to try clear up M's question.


Glad it is over , but Rick, your first example was linking from an auction to AS and that was why I said the above, of course!!
quote:
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
I think I would ask for the exact policy. Otherwise, they TOSed you because you live in England and AS if from the US?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rick said:
Why do you say that?


Because Senator said:
quote:
On further questioning, they have stated that it was due to bids being placed by suspected automated bidding software of a country of origin inconsistant with my IP address
I personally don't think ebay has any right to regulate how a person places a bid. It could be a legal issue if it were pursued. If they can say you can't use snipes, then what about the speed of your connection or your computer in general. There is no way to make all bidders "even". Heh, are they going to say you can't stay up after midnight to place a last minute snipe because that's not fair to the guy across the country who's at work or sleeping? And like someone said earlier, they are getting their cut, so basically they should just shut up about how or when the bid is placed. Ebay sometimes reminds me of the TY company when I had my gift shop and was selling beanie babies. The started telling us what we could buy,how many of each and how much we HAD to buy to get any at all. They would make us buy the ones we didn't want to get the ones we did. And then they actually came into the store and told us we had to put them in the first 10 feet of the door or we couldn't sell them at all!! As you can imagine, alot of shop owners told them were they could put their beanies! (maybe that's where all the brown dogs came from! Eek LOL ) I know from my sales experience over the summer that ebay and paypal (still ebay of course) took a good 25% of my sales by the time I added up all the fees. That's too much. Ebay needs a good competitor to make them back off the "too big for thier britches - greedies". They don't always refund the listing fee if it sells the second time either. But when you have hundreds and hundreds of listings who's really got the time to sit and sort out all the fees/ refunds and argue with ebay about it.They don't answer half the time anyway.
I'm glad you got back on senator30e, good for you for sticking up for yourself!
MG, your points were well taken. I have seen many changes in Ebay over the period of time I have used them. Some good, some not, but overall, I am pleased with my end results. Of course competion is good for any business...on the consumer end.

I know that I have sold several large items that brought much more than I could have realized elsewhere, so I suppose I did'nt mind their cut. However, MG, you are right. It is hefty!

BTW, glad to see you posting, MG! Smile
True, I do know that I sold much more than I could have without ebay. I just think they get carried away with the fees for set-up and the little "extras".
I managed to sell enough to be a "power seller", so I guess that means I paid them too much! However since my sales are seasonal I think I'll be loosing it soon.
Thanks for the welcome Mrs. M !
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
I know that I have sold several large items that brought much more than I could have realized elsewhere, so I suppose I did'nt mind their cut. However, MG, you are right. It is hefty!
Even if ebay’s cut is hefty, as long as the seller’s profit is heftier then any alternative – then ebay is providing a valuable service.

quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
BTW, glad to see you posting, MG! Smile
Did I miss something?
quote:
Originally posted by MG intern:
True, I do know that I sold much more than I could have without ebay.
That sounds like a positive experience.

quote:
Originally posted by MG intern:
so I guess that means I paid them too much!
Why do you feel you paid them too much?

quote:
Originally posted by MG intern:
However since my sales are seasonal I think I'll be loosing it soon.
Do you mean you’ll be losing the “power seller” status? Not being a seller, do you think that’s good or bad?
MG said:
quote:
I managed to sell enough to be a "power seller", so I guess that means I paid them too much! However since my sales are seasonal I think I'll be loosing it soon.
Well, I am a power seller, MG, also. Do I care one way or another? NO, I do not!! It does nothing for me! So, if I don't reach the magic goal, so be it. I have never found anything in the power seller services that meant ditz to me!

Rick said:
quote:
Did I miss something?

Do you suppose?
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
Well, I am a power seller, MG, also. Do I care one way or another? NO, I do not!! It does nothing for me! So, if I don't reach the magic goal, so be it. I have never found anything in the power seller services that meant ditz to me!
Based on M’s following quote, perhaps being a power seller is used to show prestige, or experience.
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
Mory, I am a power seller , but I have never BIN.
Perhaps buyers feel safer when they see the power seller icon. I’m not a seller, but doesn’t the seller have to apply to be a power seller? It’s not automatic is it? I assume it’s not mandatory? There must be some advantage to being a power seller?
quote:
Perhaps buyers feel safer when they see the power seller icon. I’m not a seller, but doesn’t the seller have to apply to be a power seller? It’s not automatic is it? I assume it’s not mandatory? There must be some advantage to being a power seller?


I can't remember if I applied or what, Rick. It has been some time. However, at first I probably thought it was a big deal, but I cannot tell you of one time I have used anything they offer. If I were bidding, I do not believe it would mean anything to me. My feeling on it is neither here nor there. If I have it fine and if I don't fine. But, as a whole, I love Ebay!
quote:
Originally posted by Rick:
quote:
Originally posted by Mrs.M:
Rick, look at the headline of the first link you suppied!
Try reading more than the headlines. If nothing else, look for "Germany" and the comment about sniping services.
I gather that reading assignment was accomplished.

M said:
quote:
But, as a whole, I love Ebay!
We definitely agree on that.
I just get cross eyed with all the quotes. ok...
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Rick:
Why do you feel you paid them too much?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I said...

Because you only get "power seller" when you make ebay a bunch of $$$ by selling a minimum amount monthly. A large amount!
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Rick:
Not being a seller, do you think that’s (losing power seller) good or bad?

I said....
Yea, the power seller logo. You have to continue to sell alot each month to have it. It really makes no difference to me. My feedback is good and that's what really counts.
MG said:
quote:
I just get cross eyed with all the quotes.
This post should help to exercise your eye muscles.


MG said:
quote:
It could be a legal issue if it were pursued.
They probably consulted with someone before hand to see if this was legal. It might even have been a paralegal or an intern.


MG said:
quote:
There is no way to make all bidders "even".
That’s something we can definitely agree on. I would also extend it to other areas, such as sellers and gift shop owners – especially the ones that sold beanie babies. It would even apply to competitive online auction companies.


MG said:
quote:
so basically they should just shut up about how or when the bid is placed.
Well, you could say they should have a say because it’s somewhat their bat and ball. Kind of like the signs I see in retails stores that tell people how or when to shop: “No shirt; No shoes; No service.” They don’t mention pants, but they probably assume that in that respect all buyers have been made “even”.


While I’m on the subject of T.O.S. signs on businesses (this one was on the door of a building for something in the medical industry, and no, I’m not having myself admitted or committed); I saw this one yesterday, “No solicitation; No cell phones; No handguns” (I’m not making this up). I definitely didn’t have any problem with the first two, but the last one caused me to pause. “Did they know something I didn’t?” “Should I in fact get a handgun *before* going into the building?” This wasn’t like High Noon or something, in that I don’t see a lot of people (or *any* people other than cops and what good would they be in the building if they *didn’t* have their handgun?) around town wearing handguns. This isn’t Iraq, after all. The employees knew not why the “No handguns” policy. Might be a good thing if shirts, and pants, were prohibited – easier to spot a handgun.


MG said:
quote:
They would make us buy the ones we didn't want to get the ones we did.
They can’t “make” you do anything. The last I check, the U. S. was still a quasi-free-market society.


MG said:
quote:
The started telling us what we could buy,how many of each and how much we HAD to buy to get any at all.
“Telling” and “HAD”? See response to previous quote.


MG said:
quote:
, alot of shop owners told them were they could put their beanies! (maybe that's where all the brown dogs came from!
Were you one of those shop owners or did you end up with some brown dogs, or did you already do an “I said…”?


MG said:
quote:
took a good 25% of my sales by the time I added up all the fees. That's too much.
“Took”? - Again, a voluntary transaction on your part. “That’s too much” - If too much, one can always opt to stop the relationship. I would if I felt I was paying too much for something. And, the real issue isn’t the “percentage paid to ebay”. The issue is the “percentage increase to the seller”. More accurately, how much more profit does the seller make using ebay compared to any other marketing venue. A simple way to lower the cost of selling is to use less expense selling space – such as a yard sell. But, it would be a bit difficult to get 10 to 20 million people in your yard, especially considering how many Irises would get stomped.


M said:
quote:
Ebay needs a good competitor to make them back off the "too big for thier britches - greedies".
Maybe yes – maybe no. When enough people think of them as “to big for their britches – greedies”, they will go elsewhere (there’s always an “elsewhere”, or “alternatives”). There has been other companies that have tried online auctions, and haven’t been successful, at least I think that’s the case, but I wouldn’t know because I never found one with the selection that ebay had. Ebay can’t abuse their buyers or sellers because that will encourage the buyers and sellers to stop using ebay. It will also discourage new buyers and sellers. Also, having multiple auction sites would tend to cut down on the efficiency and profit for everyone. Would the current number of buyers take the time to search multiple sites? If not, then the buyers would become fragmented between multiple services, causing unfavorable results to the sellers. Would sellers list their items on multiple sites? Same fragmentation – with similar results. Just look at the work/cost it would cause AS. They would have to double, or triple, or quadruple, their R & D to snipe multiple sites, which would probably mean an increase in fees. Of course, we would have more people on the forum talking about how AS didn’t place a snipe because one of the auction sites made some improvement.


End of eyes’ exercises.
MG said:
quote:
Oh, and in reply to your question of "had to" with the beanie babies. Yes, we HAD TO follow all those rules or we could not sell them. They would not send a single one.
So I gathered they didn't hold a gun to your head, in that is was a voluntary transaction and one that you felt was profitable enough to pursue.
quote:
Originally posted by MG intern:
Eek Quick, somebody take away Rick's quote button before I puke!!

I left extra space between the quotes so you wouldn’t puke – I’m such a thoughtful guy.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
quote:
Originally posted by MG intern:
Rick, have you ever owned and operated a gift shop?

Have you ever smoked pot? I know – I know. I’ve heard it before, “But I didn’t inhale”.

Another way of looking at it – have you ever owned and operated an auction site such as ebay, let alone on the scale of ebay?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
quote:
Originally posted by MG intern:
Me thinks you thinks too much.
It sure does beat the alternative, Don’t you think?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Now be truthful; didn’t you miss me? Just a little? Are you a Virgo?



You really should take this to General. “People will say we’re in love.”

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×