Skip to main content

Hey all, newbie here, just signed up.

There's one hour to go in the auction that I really, really would like to win. I added this auction to My Snipes, and put in the absolute maximum I am willing to pay ($257.61), with a 7 second lead. Here's my problem/question:

Before I even signed up with AS, my max bid was something like $212.52. This is what it showed when I loaded the eBay auction page as my max bid. Now, since I've signed up, added this particular auction to My Snipes, and raised my max bid (on AS), eBay is showing my max bid at only $200.01 (one cent above the actual bid price of $200.00.

My question is, is this normal? Does this happen everytime you use AS? I'm so new and confused I feel a little silly. In My Snipes, my max bid is listed correctly, the right item is listed, and everything else is correct (time remaining is matched, etc). So is this what is supposed to happen? Does AS automatically lower my bid to the lowest possible even if I actually bid a bit higher through eBay previously? Will AS only bid on my behalf 7 seconds before the auction ends?

Sorry for so many questions needing such a quick response, I am just pretty confused and considering cancelling this snipe because I really, really want this item, even if it requires manually trying to snipe it. I just really don't want AS to mess this up like I've read so much about in the past 5 minutes.

Any quick help is greatly appreciated!
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Well SWEET, it seems AS placed my max bid 32 minutes before the friggin' auction ended. What gives? Well, this really, really, really makes me want to stay with AS and start paying for this amazing service...

Seriously though, what's going on? It seems like customer service hardly has the nards to come on these forums and answer question that THEY need to be addressing... C'mon. Don't think I'll be trying this "service" again...
quote:
Originally posted by niFe:
and, well... yeah. I should've read that. Sorry. Makes sense to me now. I am an idiot.

Hey, there are a lot of aspects about AS that aren't terribly user-friendly, and AS is very good but it's far from perfect. I bet your questions and comments are at least more worthwhile to post than certain cheerleaders constantly intoning "Reliability? No problems here, everything's just peachy." I doubt everyone understands about all snipes being placed before maintenance regardless of desired timing--for that matter, AS posting a caveat like that is all fine and good but when the caveat is as at-odds with the basic point of sniping as this one is, well maybe AS should friggin sort out a way to overcome or alleviate the problem.

I'm curious about how ebay could have waffled on your max bid. Are you saying that at one point ebay showed your max bid as 212, and then it showed it as 200.01? Are you possibly mixing up 2 of 3 things, (i) your max, (ii) the minimum increment and (iii) current bid??
quote:
so couldn't/shouldn't AS flag this to the user as the snipe is set up? Err,.. yes.


I agree. The problem is one of perspective.
AS feel they have a really good system and that we are behaving like ungrateful brats when we complain!

Take me, I've been with AS for several years. I read the problems raised by others about early bids and so manually snipe, if it is really important to me. The rest of my bids are mostly "lets see if I can get this on the cheap" so I let AS do its bit. Win some lose some!

Happy Customer? Yes! No Complaints? Yup. Life is perfect? Well ....... one glitch when AS said that my $2 item was now $140 on the wrong auction, but I reset it and the snipe was placed correctly.

So no complaints then? Oh well, if you must force me to say this - No complaints at all!

So why am I a happy customer and so many of you are not?

Answer, because I regularly read these threads and learn by other's mistakes and problems. I dare say, all the regulars do, for they don't complain either!

So the problem is? AS's management, I'm afraid.

They do not confront problems, they run away and hide from their customers. Occasionally they rush out and say "sorted" "we have seen that", "it only affects .0001% of bids"

They subscribe to the "lets push it under the carpet and nobody will notice" school of management. I suspect that they are at heart "techies" rather than "lets meet the people" types.

One personal example of how it is better to come out in the open. We fitted some automatic lights for one of the largest lorry fleet owners here - a millionaire used to snapping his fingers and getting what he wanted. Our first order! The sensors broke after a month, the replacements broke, the replacements to the replacements went down and so on endlessly!

The manufacturers were Racal, one of the biggest firms in electronics. They said the new ones were fixed - they weren't. In the end the customer was so annoyed,that my engineers wouldn't go and see him, so I had to go in person and replace them!

This went on for months! As they were wired in from a central controller and nobody else did the same sort of design, we were stuck with Racal. They did get it right in the end, but it took nearly a year. I had fitted five or six new sets of sensors by then.

Later he came through with a large order for his works and his house, his son's house and his parents. £000s. I said to him years later "I was really surprised to get that large order from you" His reply is one I commend to AS "You never lied, you said you had a problem, it was evidently a manufacturer who was field testing an unfinished product and it was costing you dear. However you never abandoned us and however disagreable I was, you came back for more. I will give a firm that does not abandon us in adversity my business. I used to trade with your rivals, but they gave up at the first sign of trouble"

I really think AS should come right out - clearly state when there are problems.
e.g. As you go to snipe at ebay maintenance time on Friday
"Warning, the bid you about to place, will go in 40 minutes early - do you wish to continue?"

On this forum - a sticky warning - software problems of the following nature ......
Remedy "......." Notify us through this "quick trouble reporting link here"

OK, it doesn't make the trouble go away, but it makes us all understand the problem and turns us all into helpers rather than "bad mouthers"

What do the rest of you "satisfied" customers think?

Paul
Last edited by camera
Hey guys, thanks for the helpful comments. I truly agree with both of you. My frustration has subsided a little... But not too much because I was sniped with 4 seconds to go. Frown What a total bummer, wish it didn't have to be this way. Ah, well...

Anyway... @ petronius: Yes, I am absolutely 100% positive, beyond any shadow of a doubt that my max bid was listed as $212.??, before I even signed up with AS. Then, after I actually initiated the Snipe, bam, it dropped me to the lowers possible bid I could have while staying the high bidder. I was really, really strange... I wish I would've gotten screenshots of it. Also, the bid history list also lists $200.01.

I think something strange is happing on eBay or there might be a possibility of some weird interaction between AS and eBay... I really don't know... All I know is that I didn't win Frown
quote:
Originally posted by Camera:
e.g. As you go to snipe at ebay maintenance time on Friday
"Warning, the bid you about to place, will go in 40 minutes early - do you wish to continue?"
It seems like such a simple request. Don’t understand AS’ reluctance in not implementing this. It took a fair amount of lobbying, I think by R2, just to have a page put up during the scheduled maintenance. There really should be something more than the FAQs to warn users.


niFe - I sure hope you turned off AS' InstaMail setting.
@ Ron: I'm not saying that my max bid was displayed incorrectly from the Auction Sniper page, this is what I am saying:

1) Before I ever came across AS, I used eBay to place a max bid of $212.52. After this, the current winning bid was raised to $200.00 to beat the previous bidders highest bid.

2) I found Auction Sniper, and signed up.

3) I followed Auction Snipers instructions and added this particular auction to My Snipes, and set my max bid at $257.61 with a 7 second lead.

4) This is when the glitch occurred. As soon as the auction was imported into My Snipes and set, my max bid (displayed on both eBay and AS), was somehow lowered to $200.01, one cent above the current winning bid. Something must have happened between AS and eBay, because this has never happened before, and according to eBay policy, is NOT allowed, and definitely NOT possible.

5) As soon as Auction Sniper's maintenance began, it placed my bid. I don't have a problem with THIS because it was listed on the site (would've been helpful if it was prominently displayed, but oh well).

6) My max bid was correct after AS sniped my auction early.

I hope this clears things up. I am not pissed or anything because I lost fair and square. The max bid I placed was the max I was willing to pay, and someone sniped with a higher bid. I realize that I would've lost either way, using Auction Sniper or not.

My concern lies within this mystery glitch. The bid-confirm e-mail eBay originally sent me when I originally bid $212.52 was correct, but was SOMEHOW lowered to $200.01 after the auction was imported into My Snipes and set.

Now, again, I am not mad at Auction Sniper because this ultimately didn't change the outcome of my auction. It was just really, really wierd and makes no sense to me. Anyone have any ideas as to what happened?

In eBay's bid history, it STILL states my previous maximum bid incorrectly at $200.01. What a strange, strange glitch... Confused
So, to update...

I am now a bit happier and quite impressed with the AS service. Just won my first snipe, beating another sniper by a mere second! Sweet!

And, on top of that, I paid about $56.00 less than my max bid. No bad... AS just won more confidence in my eyes. Hopefully it will stay this way from now on. Thanks for your help and support guys!
quote:
My concern lies within this mystery glitch. The bid-confirm e-mail eBay originally sent me when I originally bid $212.52 was correct, but was SOMEHOW lowered to $200.01 after the auction was imported into My Snipes and set.
niFe,

Not sure about this, but perhaps if you post the link to the bid history, someone may be able to provide an explanation. What ever happened is definitely strange, and you are correct in that according to ebay policy, as well as their software, something like that shouldn’t be possible. There may be times when it would be nice to be able to lower a previously placed bit.
Having read all your posts, I believe the glitch is with eBay, as eBay has no way of knowing what your AS price will be. They do not even know you are going to place a bid through AS until it hits!
Therefore it is an eBay glitch, one I have experienced occasionally before, but have no answer to. I have put an eBay max price of $245.67 on an item which is currently at $215.00 and won it at $215.01. Seems impossible as the winning margin is WAY below bid increment, but it HAS happened.
Nothing is perfect it seems! But I must admit it put a smile on my face.
MOST of the time AS works perfectly for me. The times it lets me down I write off to experience. (Usually with Bid-groups, or during maintenance, which I try to avoid like the plague!)
Hope this helps.
Rob

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×